Please comment on AWallet retroactive grant: xGov#199 - AWallet - Retroactive algorandfoundation:main ← scholtz:patch-16 opened 01:27PM - 24 Apr 24 UTC (UTC) …

Hi @scholtz you had two other grants totalling 70,000 Algo for AWallet development: xGov-9 and xGov-90. Would you mind elaborating on this request a bit, for example you listed the payment scheduler on the post above, but that was funded through xGov-90? Thanks.

Hi Adri, thanks for question. the xgov-9 was proactive grant to establist the two factor authentication, redisign, and collecting new feedback. the xgov-90 was proactive grant regarding the scheduled payment. the xgov-199 is retroactive grant for work done from 2021 to 2023. is it ok like this?

Ok, got it. Perhaps modify to list the work done from 2021 to 2023 (with the repo links). Then, specify the work that has already been funded by proactive proposals and how much. Might also be helpful to provide usage stats for AWallet, so people can best evaluate its impact on the ecosystem.

i have added this sections xGov#199 - AWallet - Retroactive by scholtz · Pull Request #199 · algorandfoundation/xGov · GitHub is it ok like this?

There’s some formatting required, but it looks clearer to me.

hi, the formatting has been fixed, thx

Retroactive funding is supposed to go to projects that have contributed to Algo community significantly and irrefutably. To teams with impeccable integrity and reputation. To products that are widely implemented and used. Awallet and its team does not meat these criteria, and hence should abstain…

The voting session is already on. The objective of the discussion is not whether or not a proposal should be put forth for voting, but whether a proposal can be improved and community questions clarified before the proposal is put to vote. The community then votes for it or not.

With that said, I do agree that we need better rules around what qualifies as retroactive funding and we can make that part of the voting session 4 retro.

xGov#199 - AWallet - Retroactive

Governance Discussions xGov Proposals Pilot

Richflairstv May 5, 2024, 10:13pm 2

When will Ludo products be marketed?

Topic		Replies	Views
xGov-9 AWallet - First open source Algorand wallet xGov Proposals Pilot voting-session-1	7	812	June 4, 2023
xGov Liquidity Deployment, Request for Feedback Governance Discussions	40	888	February 2, 2024
Xgov-112 - Thurstober Tools - Onboarding Enhancements, Upgrades, and Redesign xGov Proposals Pilot xgov , voting-session-3	22	822	February 4, 2024
xGov-152: Algorand as go-to chain for Gaming (establishing the RWA narrative) xGov Proposals Pilot xgov , voting-session-3	14	1154	February 14, 2024
Xgov-113 - Thurstober Wallet Enhancer - Asset Details and Atomic Swaps xGov Proposals Pilot xgov , voting-session-3	20	820	February 7, 2024

xGov#199 - AWallet - Retroactive

Related topics