This forum is a read-only archive. Posting, replying and signing in are disabled.

Algorand Dutch Auction - What do you think?

Bert

What do you Guys think about the first Dutch Auction of Algos?

I have some concerns in terms of the limited supply (0,25% of total supply) to be distributed from a starting price of 10 USD. Also there is no information at all on future auctions or how much Algo will be sold via auctions at all. The only committment I found is that there will never be more then 10 billion Algos. So we have a lot of uncertainity, which would impact the price.

Here is Mr. Micali mentioning that Algorand Foundation is the one who is organizing the Dutch Auctions and puts the Algos into circullation (at 1:05:50):

My problem is that if you have a very limited supply, then you simply strategically target the highest paying “blind” group who might eventually commit on unrealisticly high prices (like 10 USD) due to FOMO and not being extensively educated in tokenomics & crypto. The other problem we have in this context that we are not going on an auction of Dutch tulips, where participants had a good idea about the market, product and fair prices. All the marketcap for crypto is mainly driven by speculation and not tangible value, which means it´s very hard to determine whether a price is fair, overpriced or underpriced especially in the context of having 99,75% supply not in circulation and having no accurate information when & how it enters the circulation.

To me this auction feels like you have 10 children and 100 adults on the sunny beach and make a Dutch auction on icecream and distribute 5 pieces initially starting from 1000 USD. Guess what will be the clearing price? Is this the fair or realistic market price? It´s not because your supply is strategically limited to tackle those children who would want an icecream whatever it takes.

This also suggests what to expect from future auctions, which will likely be scheduled on momentums, when the sentiment is at highest. IMO if you do a dutch auction with a higher supply (such as 600m Algo) then it´s really applied to achieve fairness & market price, however if you do it with a very limited supply (25m Algo), then it´s used for strategic targetting on the market and not with fairness in mind.

edited
Bert

this diagram has some key issues in this particular context, but nevertheless it is good enough to point out that the 0,25% supply and starting from the very high 10 USD price in a Dutch Auction is to test where the very top of the demand curve really is

MarkW

If it gets bought up at $10 Algorand will have a lot of funding.

Long term bullish.

Dont think whales will do this by themselves. A quarter billion is a very risky cost of doing business for potential return.

One thing that would be great is to pay attention to the amount of people bidding. If there are let’s say 10k bidders. On average there would be 2.5k algos per bidder. At $10 this means the average investor would need $25 k.

I dont think that’s the case. I dont see institutional investors buying yet, because there is no custody service yet.

Let’s say they will raise 100 million from this auction which is a lot of money, no matter how you put it, it will put the price per Algo at $4 .

I grew up near Dutch Orchards and where it usually comes down to is that virtually everyone will await the first part of the auction and start to fomo at 70-40% of the price.

I think most will be sold around $5 and the best deals around the $2-4 range if there still is some left.

Otherwise no algos for me until next auction.

ZAR

Hi i’m new to the forum. Agree with all comments above.

GrumpyDumpy

Yeah I have exactly the same concerns as you have and quite frankly I think I won’t be bidding after all

MarkW

This market often doesn’t make sense at all. Not enough knowledge about math and too many are plain greedy.

That being said, I am bidding below $4, hoping around a $1

Bert

Let’s assume you have a 5y investment period.

We have 10b Algos in 5 years.

IMO Algorand should have a max Mcap between 10-100b in 2024, making price between 1 - 10 USD.

I would generally look for a 10x profit over a 5 years risky investment in crypto, so a good price to buy would be between 0,1 - 1 USD depending on how bullish you are on Algorand, what is your risk appetite.

Now the likelyhood we will only have 2,5 - 25m USD funding from the first Algo auction is quite low, there will be much more “blind / dumb” money floating in.

ZAR

Agree. I will only bid under 1 dollar and more likely towards the 0.5 to 0.1 USD. Otherwise will wait to buy later on exchanges. I do quite a lot of bidding online and unfortunately theirs to many naive bidders around.

Bert

The problem I see is that bidding is not for free.

Once you load your Coinlist account the exchange rate from ETH / BTC to USD and then back from USD to ETH / BTC might cost you 10% of the capital.

So you have to risk loosing ~10% of your ETH / BTC crypto to allow you to participate in the bidding.

It is not an explicit cost as handling fee, rather cost of exchange.

Maybe, someone has precise figures on this?

Bert

I never thought about this, but as Algorand will have 2,5 billion tokens at start and auction 25 million, this immediately puts the marketcap between 2,525b - 25,25b if it sells between 1-10 USD, which is crazy.

Not sure how Coinmarketcap will calculate the 2,5 billion tokens to be held by Algorand, whether it´s in circulation or not. Actually it must be as these tokens will participate in the network consensus and receive rewards.

Actually in this sense it’s pretty smart to use 0.25% of the supply with a Dutch Auction model targetting a sales on high price to maximize the marketcap of the 25,25% of circulating supply.

edited
ZAR

The more i look at it and compare with others, the more i’m thinking fair price is more like 0.1 - 0.05 USD. I am defiantly not in for the sucker punch. No matter how good Algorand could be it’s early days.

Bert

Concerns were raised to Algorand management, if they go ahead with these auction parameters, it´s their responsibility if it backfires. We can´t do more.

Justine

Please update us here regarding the feedback. As I am hesitant to participate because of this blindspot aswell. I hate to say this but it looks moneygrab to me.

Bert

Yeah and in the meantime the pumping starts on influencer channels.

Here is one of the paid commercials:

I do like Ivan on Tech channel, it´s pretty good to be honest, but he did hide the fact of sponsorship in the video a bit :slight_smile:

Anyway I am probably also out of the auction, no matter how much I love the consensus algorithm & respect Mr. Micali.

muwonge

I wish Algorand management would reconsider the $10-0.1 range, before the auction, to something more realistic. I really love the tech! If they were to divide both number by 10, then this would be great: $1 - $0.01

GrumpyDumpy

Just bid low…If you miss it, then just move on to the next algo auction (or other project).

antoine

If you buy at 10$ and at the end of the auction the price goes to 1$ would you not get more Algos at the end of the auction?

YoungBerry

What’s even more interesting is that all the investors who participated in the auction are now interested in selling and seeing the price go even lower so that they can buy back in a year and refund for $2.16. The lower it goes, the more returns these investors will get. Given this, does anyone see how ALGO price can actually go up? Because I don’t. We have a selling pressure by the miners AND the investors are also interested in it going down. Would be interesting to watch this unfold.

Bert

I think once you sell there is no buy back anymore.

jevinoh

All you need to do is to return same amount of algo you received at the auction.

Bert

This indeed then allows for quite some crazy strategies. I am surprised about this. I would have restricted users to strictly hold their Algos on the account would they want to return it after a year. Like this indeed you had an interest to dump very fast and wait for as low price as possible to buy back.

What was the purpose of this incentive?

Gary

I’ve never been a fan of auctions of any kind, but I decided to participate in this one.

I’ve always believed that if you have a product to sell, set a price. If buyers want it and they think the price is fair, they’ll buy it. Otherwise, you can assume that the price you set is not fair and not palatable to the market.

This is particularly true of housing auctions. I see housing auctions as a way for sellers to appeal to baser human instincts in the moment, particularly FOMO, and graft more money out of the hapless bidders who often over extend themselves (thereby over inflating the market and cumulatively setting it up to crash). But who cares, right? I’ve got my money so nothing else matters.

Silvio stressed that the auction would allow the market to set the price of this new thing. It’s kind of true and it kind of isn’t. The auction set the price for the auction. Once that was over, the price on the open market plummeted like a lead balloon to begin to reveal the true value. Does the refund policy have something to do with the current price? Sure. Eventually though (how long is anybody’s guess) the market should stabilise unless another, similar auction is held. How else to get the tokens on the market though? Not another dutch auction I hope. There has to be a better way. After all, when the mint prints money, it does not auction it off.

I think the evidence indicates that the auction has failed to meet its price setting objective (although somebody is now tens of millions of dollars better off, so it met its money making objective). As an experiment, it was interesting, but it should simply be seen as an experiment, the results evaluated and the method adjusted or a new method devised if the results are not satisfactory (which is the case in my view).

This is all new. I like the technology and would like to see it succeed. The auction is a glitch that Algorand’s proponents need to address, but the concensus, forkless blockchain is a winner.