I am dissatisfied with current xGov implementation progress. And also with the proposals I have seen so far on this forum.
Here is an xGov proposal that embraces Pure Proof of Stake as a guiding philosophy and decentralises the process, whilst ensuring it is streamlined and effective.
-
Anyone with a wallet with over X tokens can submit a proposal for next Governance vote. (The amount X is to avoid spam. The amount X to be decided via Governance from a range of options). This is called an xGov Proposal.
-
Anyone with a wallet can view xGov proposals. Proposals are automatically and exclusively sorted by largest balance per submission wallet. So proposals from wallets with larger balances get seen the most.
-
There is a period of time for feedback from community on proposals before xGov voting begins, so the proposal can be amended. During this period proposing wallets cannot fall below the balance of the wallet when the proposal was made. This is to avoid proposal spam from the same token pool.
-
At the end of the proposal/feedback period proposers are rewarded from a xGov proposal reward fund, proportionally to ProposalStake / SumOfAllProposalStakes.
-
At the end of the feedback period no new xGov proposals can be made.
-
EVERYONE can then vote on each proposal, as Yes or No, if they wish. A Yes vote adds the number of Algos in the voting account to the Tally for that proposal. A No vote does not influence the Tally.
-
Sorting is updated according to Tally.
-
The proposal with the largest Tally at the end of xGov voting period gets submitted for voting in Algorand Governance.
-
Once the winning proposal is selected, for every proposal a wallet voted on, and as long as the balance of the voting wallet was maintained, they get a Reward proportional to NumAlgosInWallet / (TotalXGovVotingAlgos * TotalNumOfProposals).
-
A fresh proposal/feedback period begins, during which new proposals can be made and amended.
PS: Open to ideas for improving this proposal. Will update over time.
PPS. Also receiving a lot of feedback from AlgorandOfficial Reddit, which I am applying as above.
